Why First-Time Surrogate Kelsea Chose Pathways To Parenthood
Posted by Pathways to Parenthood | November 20, 2026Kelsea Ballard’s surrogacy journey began with friends who were struggling to grow their families, and it led her to Pathways To Parenthood, where she recently matched with her intended parents. She’s a mom of 2 who has finished agency pre-screening, and she’s now getting ready for her medical evaluation at the fertility clinic. If you’ve wondered whether you could carry a baby for another family, Kelsea’s story gives you an inside look at the early stages: choosing an agency, getting cleared and sitting down for the match meeting where it all came together.
How Kelsea’s Surrogacy Journey Began

Over the past couple of years, Kelsea has supported friends through fertility treatment and held space for them as they worked out their next steps. In the profile letter she later wrote for prospective intended parents, she described where those years took her: “This has led me to feeling fully committed to being a part of helping a family in their journey to parenthood.”
She and her husband, Ian, have a 4-year-old daughter who twirls in ballet class and a 3-year-old son who sometimes kicks the soccer ball toward the wrong goal. Ian works in IT, and the couple also runs a husband-and-wife business capturing weddings in photo and video. Their extended family lives farther away but visits often and FaceTimes the kids whenever they can. When Kelsea has free time, she’s usually meeting a friend for coffee, hunting for treasure at a thrift shop or testing a new sourdough recipe.
With 2 healthy pregnancies, a partner who backed her and a family that already felt finished, Kelsea fit the agency’s surrogate requirements before she ever applied. “While our family feels complete, I know the desire to be parents is deep and beautiful,” she wrote. “I would love to be part of your journey too.”
Why Small Felt Better Than Big When Finding the Right Surrogacy Agency
Once Kelsea knew she wanted to move forward, she had to decide what kind of support she wanted around her.
Agency or Independent?
The first question was whether to work with an agency at all. In an independent arrangement, the surrogate and intended parents coordinate screening, contracts and communication on their own. “I decided that an agency would give me peace of mind and assurance that everything is handled to protect both myself and the intended parents,” she said.
Why Pathways To Parenthood?
The large national programs came up first in her search. “I looked into big national agencies, and it felt like I would just be another number,” Kelsea said. “Becoming a surrogate feels very personal, so I wanted to find an agency that truly cares about who is matched.”
Pathways To Parenthood had things she could check for herself: reviews from past surrogates and intended parents, a team close to home, and the honesty about the process she was looking for. After that, she picked up the phone. “On my first phone call with Kerry, I just knew she is who I wanted to go through the surrogacy journey with.”
Pre-Screening: Clearing the First Hurdle
Surrogate screening happens in two separate phases, and Kelsea is between them right now. Agency pre-screening comes first, before any match is made, and covers a review of medical records from past pregnancies, a background check and a psychological evaluation. Clinic medical screening comes after matching, when the intended parents’ fertility clinic runs its own exam.
Like a lot of first-time candidates, Kelsea did her homework before pre-screening started, and the reading piled up fast. “I was a little nervous before pre-screening because I really hoped everything would be clear and there wouldn’t be any roadblocks to the journey,” she said. “I researched each part and became overwhelmed by others’ experiences in different agencies or states. That is when I stopped reading comments, forums and what the internet said and just decided to trust the journey and enjoy it as it unfolded.”
Once pre-screening began, the Pathways team guided her through each step. “During the initial clearance, Kerry and Tina helped make the whole process a breeze,” Kelsea said. “They kept me well informed, checked in, and provided support whenever needed.”
Why “It Felt Right” Meeting Her Intended Parents
Matching at Pathways To Parenthood is personal by design. Kerry brought Kelsea a family she believed shared her hopes for the experience. “When the time came to talk about matching, I was so excited,” Kelsea said. The two sides then exchanged profile letters, and after reading the couple’s, “I knew instantly that I wanted to get to know them.”
Her own letter had set the tone from the start. Kelsea told prospective parents she wanted them to decide how much contact they’d like during the pregnancy, adding, “I value open, honest and kind relationships.”
Their first phone call removed any remaining doubts. “It felt so easy to chat and get to know each other,” she said. “I got to understand their hopes for the journey and shared mine. It felt like we instantly clicked.”
Over the next couple of weeks, they texted back and forth and scheduled their match meeting. Kerry sent both sides talking points ahead of time, then led a conversation that worked through the big and small details until everyone was on the same page. “It was so great to have someone there to bring up the harder topics, and Kerry handled it professionally and with empathy for both parties,” Kelsea said.
“We officially matched the next day, as we both knew it felt right.”
Kelsea went into matching with a clear picture of the family she wanted to help, and she says the agency made sure that picture mattered. “I had hopes of finding parents who led with kindness and empathy, and Pathways To Parenthood truly cares about making sure both parties are heard and understood.”
Kelsea’s Medical Evaluation at the Fertility Clinic
Matching moves a surrogate into the second phase of screening, which takes place at the intended parents’ fertility clinic. The clinic’s physicians run bloodwork, an ultrasound and a uterine evaluation to confirm she can safely carry the pregnancy. Once she’s cleared, the process moves toward legal agreements and the medication schedule leading up to embryo transfer.
Kelsea has already had her first appointment with her intended parents’ doctor, and it left a strong impression. “Their doctor was so great in the initial meeting and shared how much he cares about the intended parents, emphasizing that my health and well-being are also a top priority,” she said. “You can tell he loves what he does and is so great at communicating the next steps.”
Her second visit means a drive of a couple of hours, and she has plans for afterward. “I reached out to the intended parents and let them know I will be there to get the final clearance from their clinic, and the intended mother and I plan to meet up after for coffee!”
Starting Your Own Surrogacy Journey
Every surrogacy journey at Pathways To Parenthood begins the way Kelsea’s did, with a single conversation. If you’ve carried at least one healthy pregnancy, are raising a child of your own and have people around you who support the decision, you may already be a strong candidate, and the full surrogate requirements cover the rest.
Submitting an application doesn’t commit you to anything. Once it comes in, someone from the Pathways team will reach out to answer your questions, walk you through what pre-screening involves and help you figure out whether now is the right time for your family. You’ll know what each step looks like before you take it, and you’ll have the same team Kelsea leaned on in your corner from that first call through matching.
When you’re ready to take the first step, start your short surrogate application.